OK, the draft is over and draft grades are starting to come in. The one I have seen so far gives Cleveland the SECOND LOWEST GRADE IN THE MAJOR LEAUGES for their 2026 draft.
Cleveland Guardians Perspective
I have been posting on Indians' forums and blogging about the Indians for most of the last 30 years. Stop by here to read interesting articles and opinions not allowed on most Tribe forums. This site is not affiliated with the Cleveland Guardians
Monday, July 13, 2026
2026 Draft - My Annual Shadow Draft
Sunday, July 12, 2026
2026 Draft - Final Comments Before My Shadow Draft
Let's start off by saying what every 'expert' says about a draft. It's impossible to determine whether a draft is a good one for 5 years. The problem with that axiom is that if you get to the end of that 5 year period, and you are a limited-resource team AND that draft stunk, you are probably struggling to put a good team on the field.
2026 Draft - Second Day Live Blog
OK, we're back at it. The Guardians opened yesterday with 4 picks:
1. Liam Peterson - RHP - Florida: This year's version of Jace Laviolette, Peterson is coming off a disappointing year. He has great upside. If you believe in high ceiling low floor in your first round college pitcher draft choice, Peterson is your guy. There is nothing NOT to like about this pick but, at the same time, Dietz or Rabe would have been much better selections to me as they just need tweaks whereas Peterson needs an overall.
5. Lucas Moore - OF - Louisville - Another LHH outfielder with great speed and ZERO power, it's hard to believe that they have niw drafted TWO Petey Halpin clones in their first 5 picks.
6. Delten LaChance - C - Oklahoma - What position in this organization did we not need to draft? Well, with Bailey, Hedges, Naylor, Huff, Ingle, Cozart, etc., the answer is obvious: CATCHER. What position are we most in need: College starting pitcher. So we drafted an incredibly slow-footed catcher meaning a position switch is also problematic. At least he hits RH and has some power. My impression of this pick is that the Guardians are chasing ranking numbers to make their draft look better. You certainly can't say that the Guardians are drafting for need.
7. Savion Sims - RHP - HS - Another highly rated HS pitching prospect, Sims, if he signs, will need a lot of work in the Guardians' pitching lab as his control of his 100 mph fastball is suspect. This is a good pick except we haven't drafted any good college SPs except for Peterson and we don't have a lot of excess draft pool since we traded away a first round pick with a $3.2 million pool value.
10. Ryan Bilka - RHP - Miami - Another college senior signing. Just padding the war chest for Schmidt and Sims. Totally nothing for the ML team for years to come, though.
Saturday, July 11, 2026
2026 Draft - Day 2 Opening Post
HOW WOULD I HAVE DONE USING MY DRAFT BOARD
2026 Draft - End of First Day Post
SUMMARY
2026 Draft - Day 1 Live Post
Thursday, July 9, 2026
2026 Draft - Part 7 - Final Pre-Draft Thoughts and Final Mock Draft
FINAL PRE-DRAFT THOUGHTS
This is the time of the draft cycle where I get the most nervous. The Guardians, ever since the 2021 draft, have, in my opinion, acted like they are the smartest guys in the draft. The 2022 and 2023 slap hitter drafts were very ill conceived. The 2025 draft of college hitters in a college pitcher heavy draft felt the same way and still does, despite those guys feasting on inexperienced pitchers in the Midwest League. The Guardians have been tied to HS hitters, college contact hitters and even some college power hitters in the first round of the 2026 draft. People have claimed that they are looking into the power hitter demographic in college and in high school. The phrase, you can never have too much pitching, should be on a big banner in their draft room. Since 2022 with Campbell and Messick, they have not drafted a quality college starting pitcher and it shows in their minor league depth and pitcher prospect pipeline close to the majors. Their minor league rotations are full of lower level college pitchers, none of whom is having much, if any, success.
Given that the 2025 draft has the potential to be one of the worst in Guardians history (IMO, the hitters success from that draft comes against lower level competition and, even then, comes with red flags like too many Ks and bad defense). We need to be following up that draft with a safer one that fills needs in our system, not a brass ring grab of HS players who have a high failure rate and clearly take a longer time to develop than college players. We just can't afford to have the Guardians act like they are the smartest guys in the room or not have a solid plan to fall back on if they get punched in the mouth by not getting their guy or their backup plan to that guy, in the first 5 rounds of the draft like I am convinced happened in 2025.
Guardians: pitching and defense wins. Draft to the part of that philosophy that involves pitching and your developmental strengths. So, that leads me to my final mock draft before the action starts tomorrow. As you will see, mine is a strange draft that has two parts: college pitching and lower ranked college power hitters. That latter group is likely to littered with organizational guys but if even one or two of those picks click to produce a ML power hitter, it will be wildly successful.
FINAL MOCK DRAFT