So, I'm wrestling with this floor/cap thing.
I'll save my thoughts on a cap, some of which I have already made, for later
Let's talk about the floor. It's supposed to be around $170 million.
So, how do small market teams make up the $80-100 million difference between where their salaries are now and the floor? The answer is simple: acquire free agents, retain your own players when they get expensive and maybe take on some salary in trades.
THE REALITY
There is no one who can convince me that a player would say "Hey, I have the choice to play in LA but I am going to Cleveland because I love sloshing around in the snow and cold during the winter...and the first month of the season". Besides the quality of life stuff, let's face it, there are financial implications. Some states don't have state income taxes. Some have cheaper costs of living. Some cities offer better income streams outside of baseball (e.g., endorsements). Also, competitiveness (perennial WS contender vs long term rebuilding team) and lineup/rotation spots that match up with players also play a part. All this, taken together, will create what I'll call a team favorability index, which will differ from player to player.
My hypothesis is that less desirable teams will have to pay more to entice the same free agent or keep their own player than a more desirable team. For example, the Washington Nationals would likely have to pay more to entice Steven Kwan to play there than the Seattle Mariners since Kwan supposedly wants to be on the west coast and wants to be on a competitive team.
So, assuming that my hypothesis is correct, how do we level the playing field to allow equal player acquisition possibilites.
So what's the soloution?
LET'S TURN FANTASY BASEBALL INTO REALITY BASEBALL
I was talking to someone the other day about this and I said "You know, this isn't fantasy baseball. You can't just have a draft and pick your players."
But maybe that's the answer. If they do put in a floor (and maybe even a cap) let's do a free agent draft.
How would that work:
All free agents are assigned a contract value by MLB in conjunction with the MLBPA. Then the draft is held with the draft order being the same as it is in the Rule 4 draft after the 5th round. The draft continues as long as there are free agents teams want to draft and have room for.
This would also work if we have a cap as teams would draft players so they fit under the cap and over the floor and ones who fit their needs.
Teams will be built on quality and need and salaries will not be an issue. Plus, teams wouldn't have to draft Skubal if they didn't want to. They may choose for a cheaper alternative and apply their resources to multiple players.
Are there problems with this system? Sure. However, all MLBPA has said is they want their players to be able to be paid. They have been careful NOT to say is that the other components of a favorability index are important. Plus, setting salaries takes away the power and need for agents and may have some implication on the anti-trust exemption baseball gets.
But I think it is worth exploring. Maybe fantasy will turn to reality. It could happen!