2026 Draft - Part 4 - Why We Need to Get Back To What Worked For Us in 2021

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

 Let me start out by saying this: the end result of a draft, in its entirety, does not necessarily represent what the intent or strategy of that draft was, going into it.

So, when you look at a draft like Cleveland's college pitcher draft of 2021, they may not have intended to take that many (18 of 21 picks) as college pitchers.  But that's how it turned out and we can learn from that draft.

In 2021, and even 2020, the Guardians selected/signed as non-drafted free agents A LOT of college pitchers, many of whom were polished pitchers with excellent stuff.  Then, after round 2 in 2022, the trend stopped.  The Guardians started drafting position players (especially LH slap hitters), high school pitchers and less college pitchers. The college pitchers they DID draft were mostly soft tossers.  As I have said from Part 1 of this series, I think it is time the Guardians get back to their 2020-2021 strategy. Right after that strategy the pipeline was full of pitching prospects who were rapidly making their way to the majors.  However, if you look at the Guardians' farm system now. It is almost devoid of impact pitching prospects who came from the draft, making our depth at AAA almost non-existent in terms of starting pitching. It's time to change that with another college pitcher draft.

HISTORY LESSON

Before talking about who we might draft in 2026, let's look at the last 5 drafts and how we got to where we are today

GUARDIANS DRAFTING SUMMARY (2020-2025)

2020

In the COVID-19 draft, the Guardians focused on HS hitters and college pitchers.  As far as the HS hitters, Tucker was clearly one of the worst #1 picks in Cleveland's draft history.  The jury is still out on what we will end up with in Tolentino and Halpin but it looks like both will end up having some sort of ML career.

As far as college pitchers, the Guardians drafted Tanner Burns (CB-A), Logan Allen (2nd rd) and Mason Hickman (5th round). In addition, they signed Cade Smith as an NDFA.

Hickman, an unranked draftee, never made it past AA.  Burns is currently a very low level prospect working out of the bullpen in AAA.  Allen has had some ML success so far and may be back in Cleveland's rotation in 2026 if injuries occur in the rotation. The undrafted Cade Smith remains as the crown jewel of this draft.

2021

In the famous college pitcher draft, the Guardians, likely by choice, selected 18 college pitchers, 1 HS hitter, 1 HS pitcher and 1 college hitter.  Here is the breakdown of the progress of those 18 guys:

ML SP - Williams (1st round), Bibee 5th(

ML cups of coffee - Aleman (10th), Nikhazy (CB-B)

AAA - Webb (3rd), Davenport (6th, injured), Mace (2nd), Dion, Leftwich, Denholm, Miller (20th round)

AA -  Johnston, Thornton, Abney, Stanley, Boone (injured), Sharpe (injured)

Released/retired - Pettway

So, almost every college pitcher from Cleveland's 2021 draft is still in Cleveland's system 5 years later or in the major leagues with another team. That is a remarkable achievement if we stopped there but there is still a chance that some of the remaining pitching prospects from that draft may get a cup of coffee or have a niche career in the majors.  To have this many players still in your organization almost 5 years after they are drafted is a testament to Cleveland's pitcher development program and gives more credence to having another college pitcher draft.

2022

The Guardians took a college hitter (DeLauter) with their first pick.  This was a good gamble at the time as he was a distressed asset who was in the comversation to go 1-1 until his junior season ended early in February with a foot injury.

However, afte DeLauter they Guardians went back to college pitching, selecting hard throwing Justin Cambell (CB-A) and Parker Messick (2nd) with their next two picks.  Both seem worth it, although Campbell's (he is up to #17 on BA's Guardians top 30 prospect)s debut was delayed for almost 4 years!

After Messick, who was somewhat of a soft tosser, the Guardians started a disturbing 2 year trend of drafting LHH college players with questionable power who were overdrafted slap hitters with good plate discipline.  Lampe, Furman, Lipscomb were drafted in the 3rd-5th rounds followed by soft tossers Dylan DeLucia (6th) and Austin Peterson (10th) and hard throwing albeit wild tosser Javier Santos (7th), HS flyer Humphries (10th) and, later one, college hard tossing relief pitchers (Ellerts (11th), Jasiak, Tulloch, Jacobs).

So, 2022 may get us two good SP in Messick and Campbell and maybe a little more in later round picks Peterson and Ellerts with the possibility of late blooming guys like Jasiak. But this pales in comparison to the depth of pitching prospects we got from 2021 and is not much better than what we got from the 5 round draft of 2020.  The reason for that is simple: we stopped drafting quality college pitchers after the 2nd round in 2022.

2023

If 2021 was the college pitcher draft, 2023 was the college LH slap hitter/HS pitcher flyer draft.

Literally, the only quality college pitcher we got out of that draft is a relief pitcher, Andrew Walters.  Yes, Matt Wilkinson is a prospect but he is a soft tosser and, despite his minor league success and notoriety due to his nickname, size and LL WS background, not a top prospect.  We even got many fewer later round college flyer relief prospects than we did in 2021.

So, from the 2023 draft we didn't get ANY help to the SP depth in our farm system.

2024

The Bazzana draft, once again, was devoid of top college pitching talent. It is highly likely that NONE of the college pitchers picked in this draft will EVER make the majors. The college pitchers they DID take were essentially organizational guys to fill out spots in minor league bullpens.  While they added some quality HS pitchers, those guys are still so far away from the majors that they may not impact this team for years.  

NOTE: Prospect evaluators and rankers are high on Khal Stephen who the Guardians got for Shane Bieber last July.  He is probably their top pitching prospect right now.  When you consider that we could have had him instead of drafting future ML backup catcher Jacob Cozart in the 2nd round of this draft, it shows just how messed up the Guardians thinking had become relative to acquiring quality college SPs from the draft vs other, less quality, prospects.

2025 

This draft had quality college pitching in the top two rounds, where the Guardians could have added up to 3 quality college SP and a quality college hitter in their top 4 picks through the end of round 2.  Drafting at #27 the Guardians missed the top tier pitchers in this draft who were already taken and a couple of the college hitters they wanted were grabbed early, meaning they were left with the HUGE gamble of strikeout-prone LaViolette in the first round.  There were so many 2nd tier college pitchers in this draft it was set up for Cleveland to grab 2-3 of the 10 college pitchers who would likely still be around when they picked at 64, 66 and 70.  Unfortunately every one of those 10 pitchers were overdrafted before our pick at 64 and all that was left in college pitchers were guys with huge question marks who slotted more in the 100+ range, talent-wise.  So Cleveland went with college hitters but did very poorly at that, ending up with a number of low ceiling, low floor guys.  As they had in 2023 and 2024, they drafted a HS flyer pitcher overdrafted a bunch of fourth tier college pitchers, and topped it off with 3 second or third tier college firstbasemen in the top 7 rounds, leaving them, one year after this draft, with what will likely be one of the worst drafts in their team history and, much worse, another draft that will likely produce ZERO ML pitchers and, therefore, ZERO college SP from the low level college pitchers they selected.

SUMMARY

The Guardians draft braintrust have screwed the ML team by not drafting quality college pitching after the top of the 2022 draft.  This organization is known for pitcher development, especially college pitchers, and not drafting to the strength of your organization in the area MOST needed by every ML team, starting pitching, borders on criminal negligence.  No resource-limited team should make this mistake, especially when their recent past has shown they can draft and develop college pitchers to quickly become impact arms in the majors.

The 2026 draft contains some qualiity college arms but if the 2025 has shown me anything, it is that you HAVE to overdraft college power SPs.  Like every draft, it will be fluid and there is a chance lowly rated college SP will bubble up to be overdrafted this year since there is dearth of quality college SPs available, with a large tier of 2nd and 3rd tier college SPs who will be projects to develop.

That being said, if we could somehow come up with 

1st round -Hunter Dietz - Arkansas

2nd round - Tyler Rabe - Ole Miss

3rd round - Cameron Johnson - Oklahoma

4th round - Josh McDeavitt - Missouri

5th round -  Matt Sauser - Central Florida 

6th round - Shane Sdao - Texas A & M

7th round - Ryan Marohn - NC State

8th round - Aiden Weaver - Duke

9th round - Ben Davis - Mississippi State

10th round - Wyatt Danilowicz - Louisville

11th round - Most intriguing, signable college pitcher available at the beginning of the 3rd day of the draft. Maybe an injured college pitcher or a guy, like Magnus Ellerts in 2022, from a small college with one plus pitch.

or something like that (I will refine this list later) would go a long way to bring college pitching talent back into this organization.  The Guardians abandoned a great strategy after round 2 in 2022. It's time to bring that strategy back for the first 11 rounds in 2026 and avoid the urge to overdraft college hitters or take flyers on HS pitchers (after trading our CB-A pick we don't have resources to do flyers this year) I think we will have a successful draft. Even if we have to overdraft some of these college pitchers, our organization will likely coach them up to be worth the round in which they were drafted.

2026 Draft - Part 3 - Impact of Trading Away Our Very High Comp A Pick

Some Thoughts For A Tuesday:

Protecting Teams From Themselves  

Part of my plan for changes to the next collective bargaining agreement is to disallow trading of draft choices completely for teams that receive competitive balance picks and before round 11 for the rest of the teams. 

Simply put, the reason for teams getting competitive balance picks is that these teams are resource-limited and are being incentivized to build from within through the draft process. 

Competitive balance picks, besides adding a highly-ranked player to a team's farm system, also come with a hefty addition to a team's draft bonus pool.  In this case the Guardians' draft bonus pool will be $3.2 million smaller as a result of this trade, significantly impacting their ability to draft and sign players to overslot bonuses in this draft.  

The trade between Cleveland and San Francisco is a shining example of why teams given this gift of an extra draft pick and enhanced bonus pool should not be allowed to spend it on anything except for what it was intended: to draft and sign talented amateur players.

Combined with Cleveland's trade in January to 'sell' international bonus pool space to the Mets, Cleveland has avoided spending close to $5 million on amateur player acquisition this year.  This is a bad, cheap look for Cleveland's ownership who have now found yet another way to be cheap and not spend money on this franchise.

BTW, for people who say Cleveland is never cheap on the draft, MOST teams are not cheap on the draft and their process in previous years is in line with what is done by most teams.  It ain't anything special.

Movement at the Middle of The First Round

My premise for the Guardians in the upcoming draft was that they needed to add top tier college pitching in most of their picks.  They were aced out of every quality college SP last year who fit their profile, making it 3 consecutive drafts without any college pitchers who weren't soft tossers.  In fact, they haven't drafted a quality college starting pitcher since 2022 where they got Messick and Campbell.  The latter is a great example of where a quality, hard-throwing college SP can have significant value even if he hasn't pitched for 3 years.  The hype around the acquisition of Kal Stephen and his high rank in Cleveland's system is another example of the value of hard-throwing top shelf college pitchers, even though Stephen's performance so far with the Guardians has been underwhelming.

So, in a draft filled with college position players with holes in their game and all the typical question marks and risk with drafting high school hitters and pitchers in the first round, I was looking at snagging quality college arm at #19.  My first couple of posts targeted Hunter Dietz as a guy the Guardians could overdraft to start them off on what I hoped would be a college pitcher centric 2026 draft.  Well, Dietz has pitched so well this year (6-0 vs the top #1 starting pitchers in the SEC) that a guy ranked as low as 60-70 this spring may have raised his stock so much that he could be gone before the Guardians can draft him.

With the lack of quality college starting pitchers available in this draft and the Guardians giving away their second 1st round pick to San Francisco, this draft is trending for the Guardians toward being a combination of high upside/very low floor guys and more LHH contact hitters with good OB skills but meh upside.  The 2025 was bad for the Guardians because they made the wrong picks.  The 2026 draft could be bad because they might not be able to draft what they really need, quality, hard-throwing college starting pitchers.  

In addition to Dietz's rise, other college starting pitchers with first round talent are performing well and are rising because every team now knows that if you want quality college starting pitching in this draft you better be willing to overdraft guys or be left with a draft without college pitchers with big upside.  

That is hugely bad for the Guardians who have one of thinnest farm systems in regards to upper level starting pitcher prospects.

The Impact of No Competitive Balance Pick

Besides the bonus pool impact I talked about above, the other major impact in the loss of the 29th overall pick is how that impacts the Guardians draft strategy and other early picks.  My plan for them was college SP, HS bat, college SP, college SP/RP, college SP/RP. has likely gone out the window as we don't have a pick to gamble with.

Without that Comp A pick, taking a HS bat early in this draft is just too big of a risk.  With essentially 2 picks in the top 94 picks, taking a gamble on a guy like Landon Thome has now gone out the window and the Guardians will likely fall back on their fatal flaw: making head-scratching picks to show everyone they are the smartest guys in the room. 

We simply cannot afford another disaster of a draft like 2025 or (excluding Bazzana) a slow developing class like 2024.  But this is what the loss of that one pick has done, in addition to basically making the 3rd day of the draft really boring for the Guardians as they just try to finish their draft with a bunch of college organizational players who will sign for slot who they feel they can develop into something more but almost always can't.

Saturday Thoughts: MORONIC TRADE!!!

 This morning the Guardians announced that they traded for two-time GG winning catcher Patrick Bailey.

This will have to go down, on the surface, as one of the DUMBEST trades in Guardians history.

The background is this:

1. The Guardians have said repeatedly how valuable Austin Hedges is to this team.  They signed him for $4 million this off-season, a large financial investment for a resource-limited team.  

2. They have THREE catchers on the their ML roster of which Hedges has value but Naylor is a weak ML backup at this point and Fry is, as a catcher, somewhere on the spectrum between emergency only catcher and starts once in a blue moon catcher.  Hedges is having a career offensive year but Naylor has been terrible on offense.

3. In the minors we have Cooper Ingle who the FO says is not ready defensively but looks like a future all-star offensively, They spent a high draft pick on overdrafting Ingle hoping they could turn him into a ML catcher and more than just a slap hitter.  I have watched him for years and right now I think he is somewhere between Fry and Naylor defensively and would be the best offensive catcher in on the team, by far, if they call him up now.

4. Behind Ingle the Guardians have Cody Huff (AAA), a good ML backup-type who can also play a little 1B and Jacob Cozart (AA), another drafted colloverege, defense-first catcher who has yet to hit much in the low minors.

In summary, the Guardians were set with serviceable bodies all the way down to AA.  Not exactly a position of need.

The trade:

The Guardians received Patrick Bailey, a defense-first (aforementioned two time GG catcher) , switch hittng catcher who is hitting .146 this year.

The Guardians traded 

1. Matt Wilkinson, a soft-tossing and seemingly pudgy LHP who was dominating at AA.  In truth, the only way Wilkinson could be a #3 starter in the majors is if he does a Messick and adds 4-5 mph on his fastball and, since he hasn't made any progress in that regard in 2+ years in the organization, I doubt if he can.  That being said, his current arsenal and competitiveness makes his floor AAAA and his likely outcome as a swingman or #5 SP.  

2. A first round pick (#29 overall) in the upcoming draft.

ANALYSIS

This is likely one of the dumbest (and there have been quite a few) trades this FO has made in the last 10 years.  Here are the reasons:

1. Bailey helps our defense but catching was not exactly a black hole on defense in Cleveland or our minor league system.

2. The trade cost us A FIRST ROUND PICK.  This was the highest possible pick that could be traded. It should be noted that trading this pick saved cheapass Dolan likely $3.2+ million doesn't have to spend on a draft pick.  It also seriously damages our flexibility in trying to sign draft picks for overslot value in the upcoming draft.  This is why teams should not be allowed to trade draft picks.

3. This trade does not help our anemic offense at all.  Bailey is hitting .146 in 2026 with a career OPS of .611.  

4. Basically this trade kills any trade value Bo Naylor has.  Not that he has much, but this will prompt conversations with other GMs that go like "Hey, I can take Naylor off your hands for a bag of balls".

5. These leaves no place for Ingle.  Obviously the Guardians value defense at catcher over offense but Ingle can hit.  You COULD say that this makes Ingle an intriguing trade chip but if the GUARDIANS are saying OUT LOUD that Ingle is a long way from being a ML defensive catcher, it is pretty obvious we would be selling low on him right now. So...

6. Bailey catches around 120 games a year.  This leaves very little time for Hedges to impact the game so while we gain on Bailey's defense we lose on Hedges' ability to impact our team.

7. It is not a secret that I waited until point #7 to mention the other piece to the trade, Matt Wilkinson.    Already stated my opinion on Tugboat above and I would have been fine with it being a Wilkinson/Alfonsin Rosario package as the potential is there.  The loss of Wilkinson does not move the needle for me on this trade but his current value and future projection is not chopped liver.  He is a good prospect if not a top 30 prospect for the Guardians. We can spit on his ability based on peripherals but you CANNOT spit on his results and guys with results, like Messick, always have the chance to be coached up.  Guys like Oscar Gonzalez and Anthony Gose, who have inherent skills, cannot always be coached up to have performance.

8. Finally, and I preface this as a possible red herring, the Guardians traded away the chance to spend MILLIONS of dollars to sign international prospects in January and now have traded away the chance to spend over $3 million to sign the #29 pick in the upcoming draft.  So, it could be intuited that the Guardians would rather NOT spend money on signing prospects.  This is why teams should NOT be able to trade prospects before the 11th round so owners can't find creative ways to avoid investing in their team.

So, there it is. One of the least impactful, cheapass, dumbass trades in recent memory by the Guardians.  This trade will do very little to help the Guardians get to or advance n the playoffs now or in the future and it has already damaged the long-term future of the team with loss of draft picks and blocking prospects in the minors.