Saturday, November 21, 2026

2026 Rule 5 Protection Lists - What Do They Tell Us?

 November 17th has come and gone. Rosters are now set in preparation for the ML Rule 5 draft, if that draft occurs. In the 2021'22 off-season, this draft did not occur because of a work stoppage.  There is some question whether it will occur this cycle due to the impending lockout.

So let's examine both the players who were added and weren't added, starting with the Guardians.

GUARDIANS

Let me start by saying the Guardians, under Chris Antonnetti and Mike Chernoff, are geniuses in this roster setting process. They routinely do not have guys selected in the ML R5 phase and, when they do, those guys most often don't stick with the club that drafted them. I trust them completely in setting their roster by knowing who to add and who it is safe to leave unprotected. 

In 2026 the Guardians added 3 prospects to their 40-man roster.  Two of them, RHP Justin Campbell and catcher Kody Huff, have a good chance to contribute to the major league team in 2027.  The third player, Jaison Chourio, is one of the top prospects in the game and played significantly in AA in 2026, making him a sure pick in the ML R5 if left unprotected.

Key players left unprotected were Franklin Gomez, Jacob Zibin and a player that many of us forget because he isn't a true prospect, Ben Lively.  Gomez and Zibin are both young pitchers who have not pitched much, if at all, above Lake County, meaning they still have two levels to conquer before they are ready for their major league challenge.  Some team may take a gamble but these two guys are the poster boys for why the ML R5 should be eliminated forever.  

The only guy of significance they did not protect is Ben Lively, who is an interesting case.  He is a successful ML veteran who is recovering from arm surgery.  He is almost completely recovered now and a smart team may take a gamble on him as a plug-and-play ML SP who can eat innings.  Given that pitchers like Lively are fetching $10+ million in free agency, getting one for a $100,000 Rule 5 fee would be a huge bargain. 

THE REST OF BASEBALL

There are 2 reasons why 2026 may be an outlier for protection against the Rule 5 draft.

1. Some teams may be gambling that the Rule 5 is cancelled like it was in 2021 and so may have left players unprotected they would normally protect.

2. In addition, there has been a recent paradigm shift for what teams look for with all the analytics available.  It used to be that teams were looking for loud tools with current useable skills.  Now teams cherish spin rates, exit velocities, etc.  But the catch-22 is that the teams protecting players know that and, in many cases, cherish those same analytic attibutes.

So, the 2026 protected list data may turn out to be an aberration compared to other years.  Hopefully, this will all be moot as, with any luck, the ML Rule 5 draft will be discontinued forever as part of the new CBA.

Let's look at the data of who teams did and did not protect, using MLB Pipeline's top 30 for each team as the basis.  As far as a player's top level, I used the highest level where a position player had played at least 18 games, pitchers had made at least 6 starts or 10 total appearances. If a player had only played short stints at multiple levels, I used his second highest level as his top.  So here we go.  Bring on the stats:
  • All 8 of the top 100 prospects who were R-5 eligible were protected.
  • 53/131 top 30 prospects were protected
    • 29/44 who were ranked in the top half of the prospects of a team's top 30
    • 23/85 who were ranked in the bottom half of a team's top 30
    • So, 15 players in the a team's top 15 were not protected, 62 who ranked 16-30 were not protected
  • Of the 53 who were protected
    • 27 played at AAA as their top level
    • 21 at AA
    • 5 at A+
    • 0 at A or Rookie level
  • Of the 78 who were not protected
    • 21 played at AAA as their top level
    • 35 at AA
    • 19 at A+
    • 3 at A
    • 0 at rookie
  • 20 prospects who were not ranked in a team's top 30 were protected
  • A vast majority of teams seemed to protect players like they thought a Rule 5 draft would eventually happen.
  • Milwaukee seemed to take the possibility of the Rule 5 the most seriously, even protecting the most players (4) who were not ranked in their top 30
  • Miami, NYM, Phil and Pitt seemed to be the most likely to be gambling that there is not going to be a ML Rule 5 draft this year

CONCLUSIONS

This year's protected list seemed to mirror most previous years with teams protecting a lot of prospects who are at AAA or AA and very few prospects who were only at A+ or A.  The top prospects not protected leaned more heavily to lower levels as players with less experience would be less likely to stick with their drafting team all year and, as a result, were less of risk to be drafted at all. 

Most top prospects were protected but very few second-tier prospects were protected.

Only a few teams treated this protection list as if they didn't think there would be a Rule 5

So, as far as who was protected, there is nothing to see here.  If we ever have this year's Rule 5 draft, we will see if there is a spike or a dip in the number of players selected and, eventually, if those players succeed or fail in the MLB.  Certainly a team with a roster crunch would think twice about protecting a guy with the skill set that Austin Peterson has since the upside is really not there with a guy like Austin.  It's all pretty much polishing up present value.

Again, as I always say in my Rule 5 draft-related articles, the ML portion of the R5 draft should be eliminated.  It simply does not work and considering how few players who may leapfrog the development line and get to the majors quicker than they would normally, it is not worth the resources that are put into the R5 draft, the roster clogging or the angst this creates for these players as most of them will only have middling/AAAA careers as there are very few gems that come out of this draft and most of those would have probably blossomed in their own organizations if this draft did not exist.

Friday, November 13, 2026

The Drafts Going Forward

 Short post as I have covered this ground before in different posts but I just wanted to summarize here.

CBA negotiations should be speeding up but there appears to be no rush. Time will tell how serious the two sides are.  

But today let's talk about what I think should happen with the drafts.  Yes, that is plural, as in international draft (new) and the existing amateur (Rule 4) draft. 

INTERNATIONAL DRAFT

This is sorely needed. Here is how I think it should work:

1, Starting in January, 2028
2. Five rounds
3. No compensation picks
4. Teams can lose their first round pick by being over luxury tax threshold
5. Bonuses for 5 rounds determined by top 150 international signings over the previous 3 years
6. No trading of draft picks
7. Teams must spend >95% of their bonus pool or be fined
8. Players must be 17 years old at the time of the draft turning 18 by the September of their draft year.
9. Each team can sign 10 NDFAs @ no more than $20,000 each before it counts against their bonus pool.
10. International signees not eligible for the Rule 5 (if it is continued).  Governed, instead, by 6-year minor league free agent rule

NORMAL (RULE 4) DRAFT

1. 15 rounds
2. Only players who are 20 years old or older at time of the draft are eligible
3. Most of draft pick rules regarding gain or loss of picks remain the same
4. No loss of draft pick for signing a QO free agent
5. All 15 rounds are slotted.   6. Draft bonuses flattened out at top so slot for last pick in the 15th round is slotted at $100,000
7. Up to 10 NDFAs can be signed per team with a slot value of $35,000 each. Overages count against a team's bonus pool.
8.  No trading of draft picks
9. Teams must use >95% of their draft pools or be fined.
10. No Rule 5 draft.  Rule 4 draft picks are eligible for minor league free agency on the following schedule
    a. Drafted when 23 or older - eligible after 3 seasons (not counting year they are drafted)
    b. Drafted when 21 or 22 years old - eligible after 4 seasons
    c. Drafted when 20 years old, eligible after 5 seasons
11. All other draft rules remain the same
12. RELATED RULE - International professional free agents are only eligible to be signed at 25 or older.

That summarizes my thoughts on drafts going forward.  What are your thoughts?

Saturday, November 7, 2026

There's A Difference Between The Results And How You Get There!

 I was thinking today about the Guardians the last decade or so, and especially the last 3 years.  

THE RESULTS

Make no mistake about it.  What the Guardians have produced the last 3 years is absolutely astonishing.  They clearly have exceeded expectations all 3 years.  No way should they have won 3 division titles or go to 2 ALCS series in that time.

No way.

But they did, thanks to Vogt, the coaching staff and, especially the players.  The phrase 'guttng it out' doesn't do their performance justice but it's the best I can come up with.

Outperformed expectations, the whole is greater than the sum of the parts, teamwork makes the dream work, getting a lot out of a little, Guards Ball...whatever you want to call it.=.

No front office, coaching staff or set of players could have ever done better.

HOW THEY GOT THERE

This is where the results diverge from ownership effort to get us over the top.  It also diverges from where the front office's decisions and gambles could easily be called into questions.  Hey, you got $100, you don't buy $100 worth of Hershey's kisses.  You buy a cow, not a bunch of magic beans, you buy Microsoft (back in the day) not a bunch of penny stocks you hope 'hit/

Well, you get my idea. 

We have had to endure the Stuart Fairchilds, Rhys Hoskins, Will Wilsons, Connor Brogdons, Estevan Florials, Scott Barlows, Tyler Beedes, Spencer Howards over the last 3 years.  Yes, a number of our own prospects failed during that time but they were our prospects and it was their first time failing.  The guys above? They had failed numerous times before they ever got here.

Face it, we tried to land Colin Holdermans but mostly landed guys who should have never, ever played in Cleveland.  Embarassingly bad guys!

Yet we still won IN SPITE of these guys and the FO who saddled this team with them.

Partly on the owner but mostly these guys are on the FO for ever allowing them to impact (mostly negatively) the team's performance.

The fact that the team could have won the division 3 years in a row having to play guys like this is mindblowing. 

SUMMARY

So, in 2027, no more of these kinds of AAAA guys.  NONE.  Give us decent FAs or give us prospects.  Hey, those prospects may fail or like Angel and Genao they may add something or, like Bazzana and DeLauter, maybe more than something.

Enough guys we have to win IN SPITE OF.  Please.

Friday, November 6, 2026

It's That Time of Year

 Free agency is just starting and fans are expecting their team to make a big splash to spice up their hot stove season.

So the Guardians picked up Jose Tena on waivers.

Now that will not immediately impact the 40 man roster that is currently at 37 with Tena.

However, this could impact the Guardians when it is time to set their roster for the Rule 5 draft.

We have 4 guys we SHOULD be protecting: Chourio, Campbell, Huff and LIvely.

In order to do that we will have to DFA someone.

While Perkins is the obvious choice, if you want a guy like Tena why not just keep Brito.

But, rosters are fluid at this time of year. These types of moves usually end up in nothing..until they do.  

Rather have led with a signing of Skubal but the suspense before they announce that signing will only add to the joy after they do announce it!
 

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Thoughts For A Wednesday - My Truth About the Upcoming CBA Negotiations

 So MLB has put another proposal together and MLBPA has spit in the face of an MLB proposal...again.

So, on an election day filled with drama MLB and MLBPA felt the need to add more.

Fine.

But thinking about the CBA and the posturing is going on, does help crystallize my 'truth'.

So here it is:

1. A cap/floor system is not going to help Cleveland sign free agents at the same salary they can get in more desirable locations.  So a floor should start low ($130 MM) and go up $10 MM per year to $180 MM)

2. Remove the draft pick loss for signing a QO FA.  If Cleveland signs a QO FA it will hurt them to lose a draft pick more than it will hurt the Dodgers or the Yankees.

3. Keep PPI and Competitive Balance extra draft picks.  These favor smaller market teams and we should NEVER do anything to change things that we currently have that favors small market teams.

4. If we limit the R4 draft to college sophomores and older, the Rule 5 could work for guys who were Rule 4 eligible.

5. Institute an international draft where kids have to be 17 at draft time to be drafted but those kids are never eligible for the ML Rule 5 draft.   Rather, they are governed by the current 6 year minor league free agent rule.

6. A floor needs to come with a $2 MM base salary in MLB, a $2.5 MM second year salary and arbitration after the second year.

7. A form of a cap like the NBA where  a team over the cap is restricted in what high-salary players you can obtain.

8. Any revenue sharing has to come with forensic accounting. 

9. Teams should not be allowed to trade draft picks.  This is a way that owners can cheap out if a floor is instituted.  Teams should ahve to spend 95% of their draft budget or be fined.

10. The MLBPA needs to start proposing tweaks to MLB's proposal instead of just rejecting them out of hand.

More later... 

Monday, November 2, 2026

Thoughts For A Monday Night - Awards Season Begins

 KWAN COMES UP SHORT

As I mentioned several hundred times in the past two months, the Guardians maximized their offense by playing Steven Kwan in centerfield this season but, in so doing, they screwed his chances of getting his 5th Gold Glove.

The GG rules say that if you split your time between two positions the one you play the most innings at is the only one you are Gold Glove-eligible for.

If the Guardians were looking (or reading my stuff either here or on X) they would have known how close he was to having more innings in LF than in CF.  

I get that CF is where the Guardians thought they needed him, but he finished with 10.1 innings more in CF than in LF.  If they had just played him one more game in LF rather than CF, he would have won his 5th Gold Glove.  Instead, he finished behind Cedanne Rafaela, who is clearly the Kwan version of AL centerfielders. 

It is a tribute to the work Kwan put in and his team-first attitude in moving to CF and doing an excellent defensive job there.  It is a black mark against the Guardians that they couldn't manage his LF/CF innings even a little bit to make sure he qualified as a left fielder where he is head and shoulders above any other AL left fielder.

BIBEE IS GOLDEN

Congratulations to Tanner Bibee.  He had a tough year this year but he at least came away with his first Gold Glove and, frankly, he probably should have had one last year with his athleticism and top shelf pickoff move.

PARKE MESSICK = PPI Pick

I have been saying for two months now how the Guardians should forget about pimping Messick as the AL ROTY because he had two strikes against him with the way Kevin McGonigle played most of the season.  

I said over and over again that the Guardians should be pimping him for the AL Cy Young award as just being a finalist would give the Guardians PPI draft pick next year.  To show how valuable that is, the pick we would get would be essentially equivalent to the one that got us Patrick Bailey this year, assuming we don't sign one of 8 free agents who have a qualifying offer, in which case we would forfeit that pick as it would be our second pick in the draft..  

So, while we all would love to see Parker win the Cy Young AND ROTY (or either, actually) the important thing for the team is that his performance got us a huge draft pick next year.

CADE SMITH 

Cade is a finalist for reliever of the year and it is well-deserved.  What a great season he had this year and we are extremely lucky as a team to have him as our closer.  What a great close he is! Thanks, Cade for a great season.

So, that's it for now.  More awards coming up but, so far, it's been a good off-season for the Guardians.


Sunday, November 1, 2026

Changes To The Draft And Prospect Retention In The New CBA

 Over the last year I have written several articles on changes in the new CBA that could, in my opinon, help baseball.  As we approach the lockout, I wanted to refresh those and will begin by talking about a few ways I see that the process of acquiring amateur talent could be helped.  Some of this is under the framework set up by proposals from the MLBPA and MLB on the subject.  

1. Eliminate Drafting of High School Players in the Rule 4 Draft

This has been proposed by MLB, likely because these players come with the highest risk and, generally, require much larger bonuses than college kids. The plan is to limit drafting of players to college sophomores and above. The perception that MLB owners are cheap SOBs is just dripping from this proposal.

After thinking about it, however, I agree with not drafting HS players because:

(1) Only about 50 top-ranked HS kids (75-80 total HS players) are drafted each year with not all of them signing.  About 50% of top-ranked HS prospects are not even drafted, likely based on salary demands fueled, in some cases, by whether teams think those demands are in line with their talent.
(2) Losing these players from the draft pool would not impact:
    (a) the long-term quality of the draft (just make the draft 2-3 years later that much stronger)
    (b) the quality at the bottom of the next couple of drafts, especially if the draft was shortened, would not suffer as the differences between players near the end of the draft is small and certainly any differences are in the eye of the beholder.
(3) The current Rule 5 (and proposed changes to that draft) generally exposes HS players to that (R5) draft well before they are ready to make their ML debuts.
(4) The maturity level of 17/18 year old HS players makes it non-optimal for them to go into professional baseball right out of high school where they would be dealing with older players and outside influences that could easily have a detrimental effect on their development.
(5) Eliminating HS players from the draft eliminates the perceived negative impacts (costs, time consumed, pressures) of the travel ball/showcase circuits.  That is, the goal would switch from being one of a few HS players to get drafted to one of many HS players who will earn college baseball scholarships. It also removes any coaching designed to highlight attributes that pro scouts are looking for compared to the more developmental attributes college coaches would be looking for.
(6) The House vs NCAA settlement actually helps as college teams can now have up to 34 full scholarship players instead of the previous limits of 13.7 full scholarships that could be divided between all players on a college team.  This, plus NIL money, could make it more comfortable for these players to go to college before they turn pro, giving them extra experience to make them more ready for pro ball. MLB needs to lean into this by setting up a competitive scholarship fund for needy players, including NIL opportunities for those players.
(7) While I hate the ML Rule 5 draft and want it discontinued, if it stays, eliminating high school players from the draft could allow for the proposed changes to the R5 draft (i.e., players to be R5 draft eligible one year sooner than they are now) to be more doable as college sophomores and juniors could, in theory, take 2-3 years less to get to the majors than HS kids would.

While I agree with not including HS players in the draft going forward, this would have to come with other changes to the draft.

2. Other Changes To The Rule 4 Draft

(1) 15 round draft (to help account for the lack of HS players in the draft)
(2)  All picks in those 15 rounds have slot bonuses assigned (same range as before, just spread out over 15 rounds).
(3) No trading of draft picks before those in the 11th round, Teams receiving competitive balance picks would not be eligible to trade draft picks, only receive draft picks in trades.
(4) Unlimited signing of NDFAs with a cap on $100,000 per NDFA with excess bonuses counted against bonus pool [NOTE: this is vastly different than the owners' proposal which limits the bonuses to $1000 for NDFAs and limits the number of NDFAs that a team can sign].
(5) Draft-and-follow of JUCO players eliminated...again
(6) Teams have to spend at least 95% of their draft budget or be fined

3. Establishment of An International Amateur Draft

The current international amateur signing system is seriously flawed and ripe with the opportunity for corruption.  At the same time, the reality is that the socioeconomics don't favor one set of rules for Rule 4 and international amateur player acquisitions. So here is what I consider a fair system if MLB institutes an international amateur draft.

(1) 5 rounds/150 players at most
(2) Draft in January so players can play in the DSL that summer
(3) Age limit for draft will be at least 17 years old at the time of the draft
(3) Draft order is based on reverse order of finish from previous year.  No compensation picks like those in the R4 draft.
(4) Bonus slots will be based on top 150 international bonuses from each of the last 2 years 
(5) International amateur NDFAs could sign for up to $10,000 without counting against a teams bonus pool.
(6) No trading of international draft picks
(7) Teams must spend at least 95% of their international bonus pool or be fined
(8) OPTIONAL: Teams receiving competitive balance picks will be granted an additional $2 MM per draft to their draft pool
(9) International signees would not be eligible for the ML R5 draft and their minor league free agency would be governed by the current 6-year minor league free agent rules.

4. Rule 5 Draft and Minor League Free Agency 

(1) The changes in the Rule 5 draft have been mentioned above for Rule 4 (and international amateur) draftees and NDFAs
(2) Players obtained through the Rule 4 draft process (draftees and NDFAs) will be eligible for minor league free agency if they turn 25 before the end of the regular season if they are not placed on a major league roster by November 1st. International amateur players would become minor league free agennts by the same rules that currently exist for minor league free agents.