- All 8 of the top 100 prospects who were R-5 eligible were protected.
- 53/131 top 30 prospects were protected
- 29/44 who were ranked in the top half of the prospects of a team's top 30
- 23/85 who were ranked in the bottom half of a team's top 30
- So, 15 players in the a team's top 15 were not protected, 62 who ranked 16-30 were not protected
- Of the 53 who were protected
- 27 played at AAA as their top level
- 21 at AA
- 5 at A+
- 0 at A or Rookie level
- Of the 78 who were not protected
- 21 played at AAA as their top level
- 35 at AA
- 19 at A+
- 3 at A
- 0 at rookie
- 20 prospects who were not ranked in a team's top 30 were protected
- A vast majority of teams seemed to protect players like they thought a Rule 5 draft would eventually happen.
- Milwaukee seemed to take the possibility of the Rule 5 the most seriously, even protecting the most players (4) who were not ranked in their top 30
- Miami, NYM, Phil and Pitt seemed to be the most likely to be gambling that there is not going to be a ML Rule 5 draft this year
I have been posting on Indians' forums and blogging about the Indians for most of the last 30 years. Stop by here to read interesting articles and opinions not allowed on most Tribe forums. This site is not affiliated with the Cleveland Guardians
Saturday, November 21, 2026
2026 Rule 5 Protection Lists - What Do They Tell Us?
Friday, November 13, 2026
The Drafts Going Forward
Short post as I have covered this ground before in different posts but I just wanted to summarize here.
CBA negotiations should be speeding up but there appears to be no rush. Time will tell how serious the two sides are.
But today let's talk about what I think should happen with the drafts. Yes, that is plural, as in international draft (new) and the existing amateur (Rule 4) draft.
INTERNATIONAL DRAFT
This is sorely needed. Here is how I think it should work:
Saturday, November 7, 2026
There's A Difference Between The Results And How You Get There!
I was thinking today about the Guardians the last decade or so, and especially the last 3 years.
THE RESULTS
Make no mistake about it. What the Guardians have produced the last 3 years is absolutely astonishing. They clearly have exceeded expectations all 3 years. No way should they have won 3 division titles or go to 2 ALCS series in that time.
No way.
But they did, thanks to Vogt, the coaching staff and, especially the players. The phrase 'guttng it out' doesn't do their performance justice but it's the best I can come up with.
Outperformed expectations, the whole is greater than the sum of the parts, teamwork makes the dream work, getting a lot out of a little, Guards Ball...whatever you want to call it.=.
No front office, coaching staff or set of players could have ever done better.
HOW THEY GOT THERE
This is where the results diverge from ownership effort to get us over the top. It also diverges from where the front office's decisions and gambles could easily be called into questions. Hey, you got $100, you don't buy $100 worth of Hershey's kisses. You buy a cow, not a bunch of magic beans, you buy Microsoft (back in the day) not a bunch of penny stocks you hope 'hit/
Well, you get my idea.
We have had to endure the Stuart Fairchilds, Rhys Hoskins, Will Wilsons, Connor Brogdons, Estevan Florials, Scott Barlows, Tyler Beedes, Spencer Howards over the last 3 years. Yes, a number of our own prospects failed during that time but they were our prospects and it was their first time failing. The guys above? They had failed numerous times before they ever got here.
Face it, we tried to land Colin Holdermans but mostly landed guys who should have never, ever played in Cleveland. Embarassingly bad guys!
Yet we still won IN SPITE of these guys and the FO who saddled this team with them.
Partly on the owner but mostly these guys are on the FO for ever allowing them to impact (mostly negatively) the team's performance.
The fact that the team could have won the division 3 years in a row having to play guys like this is mindblowing.
SUMMARY
So, in 2027, no more of these kinds of AAAA guys. NONE. Give us decent FAs or give us prospects. Hey, those prospects may fail or like Angel and Genao they may add something or, like Bazzana and DeLauter, maybe more than something.
Enough guys we have to win IN SPITE OF. Please.
Friday, November 6, 2026
It's That Time of Year
Free agency is just starting and fans are expecting their team to make a big splash to spice up their hot stove season.
So the Guardians picked up Jose Tena on waivers.
Wednesday, November 4, 2026
Thoughts For A Wednesday - My Truth About the Upcoming CBA Negotiations
So MLB has put another proposal together and MLBPA has spit in the face of an MLB proposal...again.
Monday, November 2, 2026
Thoughts For A Monday Night - Awards Season Begins
KWAN COMES UP SHORT
Sunday, November 1, 2026
Changes To The Draft And Prospect Retention In The New CBA
Over the last year I have written several articles on changes in the new CBA that could, in my opinon, help baseball. As we approach the lockout, I wanted to refresh those and will begin by talking about a few ways I see that the process of acquiring amateur talent could be helped. Some of this is under the framework set up by proposals from the MLBPA and MLB on the subject.
1. Eliminate Drafting of High School Players in the Rule 4 Draft